A former fraud investigator for the New York City Department of Homeless Services (DHS) has been sentenced to 27 months in prison after being convicted of stealing personal information from homeless individuals. The investigator, who was entrusted with protecting the city’s most vulnerable populations, instead used his access to commit identity theft and fraud.
The man, aged 41, worked as a fraud investigator responsible for verifying that people seeking help from DHS, such as shelter or other homeless services, were eligible. Instead of doing his job to protect resources and ensure fairness, he misused his authority. By accessing a database that stored sensitive personal information, he stole the identities of over ten homeless individuals. The stolen information included names, Social Security numbers, and birth dates—details provided by victims who trusted the system to protect them.
How the Scheme Unfolded
Once he had access to this sensitive information, he conspired with another individual to carry out a fraudulent scheme. The fraud investigator texted the stolen personal details to his accomplice, who then submitted fake applications for unemployment benefits. These benefits were filed in the names of the homeless victims—without their knowledge or consent—and were intended to be split between the conspirators.
Manvel Resident Antonio Jackson Admits to Fraud Totaling $2 Million
This scheme took advantage of financial aid programs meant to help those in need during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, a time when unemployment rates were high and relief funds were critical for many struggling families. The stolen benefits added up to significant sums, further diverting money meant to support those facing real hardship.
Victimizing the Vulnerable
The victims in this case were already some of New York City’s most vulnerable residents. Homeless individuals often turn to DHS as a last resort for shelter and basic assistance, relying on the agency to protect their privacy and provide security during tough times.
Unfortunately, their trust was cruelly exploited. The fraud investigator targeted people who were unlikely to know their identities were being used for criminal purposes, as many of them lacked stable housing or access to regular communication. This betrayal caused not only financial harm but also emotional distress for those who relied on DHS to safeguard their personal information.
Accountability and Sentencing
In July 2024, the fraud investigator admitted to his role in the scheme and pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and aggravated identity theft. His co-conspirator also pleaded guilty and will face sentencing in March 2025.
Carlos Santos Pleads Guilty to Running a Multimillion-Dollar Fraud Scheme
During sentencing, federal prosecutors underscored the seriousness of the crime. They emphasized that the investigator abused his position of trust to prey on the very people he was supposed to help protect. His actions undermined the mission of DHS and damaged the reputation of a system designed to support the most vulnerable.
Condemnation by Law Enforcement
Officials from the FBI and the New York City Department of Investigation (DOI) publicly condemned the actions of the former investigator. The FBI described the crime as an egregious abuse of power, highlighting how it violated the rights and privacy of homeless individuals. The DOI reinforced its commitment to holding public employees accountable, ensuring that those who misuse their roles for personal gain face consequences.
The sentencing judge agreed with prosecutors and handed down a 27-month prison term. The punishment was intended not only to hold the fraud investigator accountable but also to send a message to other public employees that abusing positions of power will not be tolerated.
Damage to Public Trust
The consequences of this crime extend beyond the stolen benefits. It damaged public trust in a system designed to help people during their most vulnerable moments. Homeless individuals, who already face significant challenges, were left to deal with the aftermath of having their identities stolen.
While the fraud investigator faces prison time, the harm caused by his actions—both to his victims and to the integrity of public services—will have lasting effects. This case stands as a grim reminder of the damage that can result when those in positions of trust betray the very people they are supposed to serve.
